HomeResearch and NewsArbat Capital: Banking Sector Report - January 2020

Arbat Capital: Banking Sector Report - January 2020


US banks declined significantly in January after very strong performance in 2019. Thus, the broad market was underperformed substantially after 4 months in a row of leading dynamics. Thus, BKX index decreased by 7.6% MoM in January vs -0.2% MoM of SPX index. Absolute January performance on MoM basis was -1.2 std from the mean and it is in the bottom 1% of absolute MoM performance of BKX index. Relative January performance was -7.4% MoM, it is -1.6 std from the mean and it is in the bottom 6% of relative MoM performance vs SPX index since 1992. It was the worst start of the year on absolute basis over the last 4 years and the third worst January on relative basis over more than 28 years.

Banking quotes were driven by quarterly results and coronavirus threat. So, banks with better quarterly figures demonstrated positive dynamics. However, banks which missed estimates fell significantly more in absolute terms than banks which beat estimates rose. Thus, all 5 worst performers lost more than 10% MoM in January.

US banks reported better than feared headline numbers due to strong capital markets revenues but net income was negative on yoy basis for the second quarter in a row. NII and NIM remains a drag for US banks as well as loan growth is still relatively weak but we see some stabilization of NIM, still strong credit quality and managed CECL impact while opportunities for expense control and positive operating leverage have reduced. Thus, 17 out of 24 of our group of banks demonstrated positive EPS surprises, in line with median number of positive quarterly EPS surprises over the last 51 quarters but slightly lower than a number of positive EPS surprises in the first 3 quarters of 2019. Thus, median EPS surprise for our group of banks was +3.6% vs median quarterly figure over the last 12.5 years of 3.5%. Moreover, revenue surprise was also positive, the 21th quarter over the last 23 quarters, +0.6% vs median quarterly figure over the last 12.5 years of 0.8%. 17 companies of our group of banks, or 71%, demonstrated positive surprise on revenue, markedly higher the median quarterly figure since Q1 2007 of 62%. Surprisingly, market perception of the results was negative for the first time over the last 6 quarters – median percent change in price around the earnings date of our group of banks was -1.7%, markedly lower than median figure since Q1 2007 of -0.25%. BKX index decreased by 6.3% since the start of the earnings season till the end of January while S&P 500 index lost only 1.9% over the same time, but the key reason of significant decline was coronavirus fears rather than quarterly results, from our point of view. Notwithstanding, consensus estimates were almost unchanged qtd. Thus, 1Q20 EPS estimate was revised down by 0.4% qtd / -0.3% since 13 January (median of BKX index members), FY20 EPS estimate was +0.1% / -0.1% since the start of the earnings season while median change of FY21 EPS estimates was +0.3% qtd / +0.2% since 13 January.

Median growth of non-interest revenue of BKX index members was +0.4% qoq or +11.4% yoy, the strongest yoy growth since 4Q12. It was mainly driven by capital markets but we don’t expect that the growth is sustainable given its volatility, high valuations of US markets and inevitable growth of risks in the middle of the year because of elections. In turn, median decline of NII of BKX index members was 0.4% qoq or -2.0% yoy vs -0.7% qoq or flat yoy dynamics in 3Q19. On qoq basis, it was the fourth quarter of decline in a row. The key driver of negative NII dynamics remains ongoing NIM decline after three rate cuts in 2019 but it was slightly better than consensus estimates in 4Q19. From the other hand, median NII surprise of BKX index members was -0.1% (vs estimates as of January 13), negative for the second quarter in a row. Given current rate estimates, we expect that NIM will continue to decline in 1H20 but it will stabilize in 2H20. However, it all depends on the future fed’s policy. For example, a number of banks expect that the rate will be lowered at least once in 2020. Also, opex was again higher than expected. In result, operating leverage of BKX index members was negative in 4Q19 for the second quarter in a row after 9 consecutive quarters being positive. And we don’t expect that banks will be able to demonstrate significant positive operating leverage in 2020 even despite still good expense control given challenging revenue environment and necessity to invest in technology.

Overall, operating trends of US banks were solid so far but gradually deteriorating. So, we still see almost no EPS drivers in the near future except for high buybacks with rising political uncertainty given election year even despite diminished risks of trade war and Brexit recently. At the same time, banks continue to trade with significant discount to historical averages while discount to S&P 500 index has decreased significantly even despite late cycle concerns. Thus, banks are trading with -1.3 / -1.9 std on P/E CY and -1.3 / -1.9 on P/E NY (on the basis of samples from 2000 and 2010 years to current moment) relative to historical averages (as of January 31). As for relative to S&P 500, banks are currently trading at -1.3 and -1.4 std from the sample mean (2010-current moment) for P/E CY and P/E NY, respectively. So, we are neutral on US banks until we see macro and rate environment improvements.

EU banks decreased in January after 4 consecutive months of positive absolute performance. On relative basis, it underperformed the broad market again, after two years in a row of significant underperformance. On absolute basis, SX7P index decreased by 5.1% MoM in January or -0.8 std from the mean and this result is in the bottom 19% of absolute monthly performance of SX7P since the index inception. Also, relative monthly performance was -3.9% MoM or -1.0 std and it is in the bottom 12% of relative monthly performance. Despite weak relative dynamics in two previous years when SX7P index underperformed the broad market by 12.1% and 17.1% in 2018 and 2017, respectively, EU banks showed the worst January relative performance over the last 4 years.

The key drivers of EU banks in January were also the start of the earnings season and risks associated with coronavirus. So, the worst performers were Spanish banks which significantly missed expectations. Thus, Banco Sabadell lost more than 20% of its market cap in January. In turn, banks with better results increased significantly but the best January performance was demonstrated by DBK which quarterly figures were in-line but progress in restructuring was the reason for relief rally in the last days of the month.

EU macro data published in recent months were slightly better than expected pointing to possible stabilization in EU economy in the near future, especially if coronavirus risk is resolved quickly. But EU GDP added just 0.1% qoq in 4Q19, missing consensus of +0.2%, because of unexpected decline of both French and Italian GDP on qoq basis. Composite PMI also missed estimates in January but it remains above 50 pts. Despite January ECB meeting was uneventful, it was noted again that ECB’s baseline scenario of ongoing but moderate growth of economy of euro area is intact. Start of the earning season was relatively neutral as better/worse results were shared equally, thanks to strong capital markets revenues, which is not bad, given clearly weak results in previous quarters. Despite all above,

EU banks EPS estimates continue to go down because of negative rate environment and still relatively weak macro, but the rate of estimates decline has decreased. So, EU banks continue to trade with significant discount to historical averages (-18% / -1.1 std from mean P/E CY of SX7P index members, sample from 2010 to the present) but discount to US peers (on median P/E CY of BKX index vs SX7P index) is 17.7% at the moment vs average of 15.7% since 2010 or -0.4 std, still minor, given higher risks associated with EU banks. However, if macro and earnings stabilization continues, we could see short-term rally in EU banks in the near future, given underperformance in 2 previous years.

Download PDF

investment, banks;

Read more

Oil Market Report - September 2022

As the crude oil market is experiencing its largest 90-day decline since March-April 2020, which was only exceeded prior to 2020 by market routs in 2014-15 and 2008-09, we see the limited downside in crude oil prices from the levels achieved and believe that the market would pass its trough before the winter starts as the fundamentals remains rather tight and only would get tighter in a couple of quarters ahead. On the demand side, both the OPEC and the IEA expected a rather robust growth of the global oil consumption in 2023, driven mainly by jet fuel and robust oil use for power generation in the Middle East and in Europe due to record natural gas and electricity prices. In addition, petroleum product markets, especially diesel, are expected to remain in deficit in coming quarters due to downstream capacity constraints outside of China as lower Chinese export quotas have sharply reduced its sales abroad and newly introduced taxes in India have discouraged exports from Asia’s largest supplier. 

oil, investment

Banking Sector Monthly Report - August 2022

US banks outperformed the broad market slightly in August 2022, for the first time over the last three months. However, BKX index ended the month in the red, for the 5th time out of the first 8 months of 2022. BKX index decreased by 2.4% MoM in August 2022 vs -4.2% MoM of SPX index. Absolute August performance was -0.5 std from the mean monthly performance, and it was in the bottom 28% of absolute monthly performance in the index history. 

investment, banks;

Oil Market Report - July 2022

Crude oil prices surged further in June 2022 for the second consecutive month, with ICE Brent and NYMEX WTI first-month contracts averaging nearly 5% higher on a monthly average basis despite a relatively volatile month and tumbling financial markets. The market was driven by a strong supply/demand outlook in the short term and geopolitical developments in major producing regions. The ICE Brent front-month contract increased by $5.54 in June 2022, or +4.9%, to average $117.50 / bbl, and NYMEX WTI front-month contract rose by $5.08, or +4.6%, to average $114.34 / b. 

oil, investment